Skip to content
Guides

New customer calls and existing customer calls are different

Regulars forgive a missed call. Strangers don't. How to treat the two differently, including putting existing customers straight through to you.

The short version
  • Existing customers want you; new callers want anyone who answers.
  • A transfer rule can put existing customers through and capture everyone else.
  • Returning callers are recognised and greeted by name.

Two callers, two sets of expectations

A customer you have worked for rings with a question about their job. If you miss it, they text, or try again later, because they want you in particular. A stranger rings because your name came up in a search. If you miss it, they try the next name. The same unanswered call has opposite outcomes depending on who made it.

Most businesses treat every call the same way, usually by letting them all go to one voicemail. That serves the regulars tolerably and loses the strangers.

What new callers need

A new caller needs three things quickly: to be answered, to be asked sensible questions, and to be told what happens next. They don't need you personally at that moment. A receptionist who takes the job, the place and the number, and answers basic questions about what you do, has done everything the first call needs. You then ring back informed.

What existing customers need

An existing customer usually needs you or your team. They have a booking to move, a question about an invoice, or something has gone wrong. Asking them to describe it all to an assistant can feel like a barrier. The better experience is to get them to a person fast, or at least to recognise who they are.

Lead Capture AI does two things here. Returning callers are recognised by their number, so she greets them by name instead of treating them as a stranger. And on the Front Desk plans you can set a transfer rule in plain English.

Setting a transfer rule

A transfer rule has two parts: a number to ring, and a sentence describing when. For example: 'Ask at the start whether they already have a booking with us. If they do, put them through. Otherwise take their enquiry.' She asks the question, and existing customers are connected to your phone with their own number showing.

If nobody answers within about twenty seconds, she comes back on the line and takes the caller's details, so a missed transfer doesn't lose them. The call is still logged with its transcript and a note that it was put through. She never offers a transfer when the rule isn't met and never reads your number aloud.

Using a call menu instead

Some businesses prefer callers to choose for themselves. An optional call menu can play first: press 1 for a new enquiry, 2 for the team, for example. It is off by default, takes a couple of minutes to switch on, and if the caller presses nothing they go to the receptionist as normal. Each enquiry is tagged with the option chosen, so you can see how many callers were existing customers.

Either way, the principle is the same. Decide who needs a person and who needs an answer, and stop sending both to a beep.

Questions people ask

Can existing customers be put straight through to me?

Yes, on Front Desk and Front Desk Pro. You write a rule such as putting through anyone with an existing booking, and give a number to ring. If you don't answer, she takes their details.

Does the receptionist recognise people who have called before?

Yes. Returning callers are recognised by their phone number and greeted by name, so regulars are not asked to start from scratch.

Should I use a call menu or a transfer rule?

A transfer rule keeps the call conversational: she asks and routes. A menu lets callers choose by keypad. Menus suit businesses with distinct departments; a rule suits most small businesses.

This is what Lead Capture AI does for you

She answers the calls you can’t, knows your business, and texts you the details in seconds. Your number is live the day you sign up, and the first 7 days are free with no card.